Uploaded image for project: 'eCQM Issue Tracker'
  1. eCQM Issue Tracker
  2. CQM-1915

Measure fails to distinguish first visit

XMLWordPrintable

    • Icon: Implementation Problem Implementation Problem
    • Resolution: Answered
    • Icon: Minor Minor
    • Measure
    • Vendor/Epic
    • Hide
      Thank you for your insightful feedback. We will assess and determine whether there are alternate approaches to express the intent of the measure in the upcoming annual update. We welcome suggestions for alternate approaches from other measure developers and measurement experts as well. Furthermore, we think this would need broader discussion with measure development and eCQM community. We are open to receiving feedback from vendors and implementers on how their system handles CMS161.
      Show
      Thank you for your insightful feedback. We will assess and determine whether there are alternate approaches to express the intent of the measure in the upcoming annual update. We welcome suggestions for alternate approaches from other measure developers and measurement experts as well. Furthermore, we think this would need broader discussion with measure development and eCQM community. We are open to receiving feedback from vendors and implementers on how their system handles CMS161.
    • Measure not calculating as intended
    • Hide
      CMS161 looks at the Percentage of patients aged 18 years and older with a diagnosis of major depressive disorder (MDD) with a suicide risk assessment completed during the visit in which a new diagnosis or recurrent episode was identified.
       
      This measure is intended to only require a suicide risk assessment at the visit where a new or recurrent episode of Major Depressive Disorder (MDD) is started. Measure implementers have given us feedback that capturing a new or recurrent episode of Major Depressive Disorder (MDD) to identify the initial population/denominator has been challenging, as MDD diagnosis starts and stops during the encounter. Every visit for MDD is showing up as a new episode of MDD. After discussion, the clinical experts agreed that the logic should be modified and to introduce a look back period of 105 days, such that an episode of MDD would only be considered to be a recurrence if the patient has not had an MDD-related encounter within the past 105 days, thus eliminating routine visits for an ongoing case of MDD from the measure.

      https://ecqi.healthit.gov/ep/ecqms-2017-performance-period/adult-major-depressive-disorder-mdd-suicide-risk-assessment


      Propose revising the initial population logic by introducing a look back period of 105 days in order to limit the initial population to patients with a new or recurrent episode of MDD (if there is a gap of >=105 days between visits for MDD, clinical experts suggest that would imply a recurrent episode). PCPI also proposes to revise the classification of the ‘Major Depressive Disorder-Active’ diagnosis as an attribute of an encounter to ensure that the encounter is related to patient’s MDD.
      We seek feedback on the following proposed logic:
       
      Current logic:
      •Initial Population =
      ◦AND: Age>= 17 year(s) at: "Measurement Period"
      ◦AND: "Diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active" starts during Occurrence A of $MDDEncounters161
      •Denominator =
      ◦AND: Initial Population
      Variable:
      •$MDDEncounters161 =
      ◦Union of:
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psych Visit - Diagnostic Evaluation"
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psych Visit - Psychotherapy"
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Emergency Department Visit"
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Office Visit"
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Outpatient Consultation"
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psychoanalysis"
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Face-to-Face Interaction"
      ◾during "Measurement Period"
       
      Proposed logic:
       
      •Initial Population =
      ◦AND: Age>= 17 year(s) at: "Measurement Period"
      ◦AND: Occurrence A of $MDDEncounters161
      ◦AND NOT: Occurrence B of $MDDEncounters161 < 105 days ends before start of Occurrence A of $MDDEncounters161
      •Denominator =
      ◦AND: Initial Population
       
      Variable:
      •$MDDEncounters161 =
      ◦Union of:
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psych Visit - Diagnostic Evaluation (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)”
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psych Visit – Psychotherapy (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)”
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Emergency Department Visit (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)”
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Office Visit (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)”
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Outpatient Consultation (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)”
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psychoanalysis (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)”
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Face-to-Face Interaction (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)”
      ◾during "Measurement Period"
      Show
      CMS161 looks at the Percentage of patients aged 18 years and older with a diagnosis of major depressive disorder (MDD) with a suicide risk assessment completed during the visit in which a new diagnosis or recurrent episode was identified.   This measure is intended to only require a suicide risk assessment at the visit where a new or recurrent episode of Major Depressive Disorder (MDD) is started. Measure implementers have given us feedback that capturing a new or recurrent episode of Major Depressive Disorder (MDD) to identify the initial population/denominator has been challenging, as MDD diagnosis starts and stops during the encounter. Every visit for MDD is showing up as a new episode of MDD. After discussion, the clinical experts agreed that the logic should be modified and to introduce a look back period of 105 days, such that an episode of MDD would only be considered to be a recurrence if the patient has not had an MDD-related encounter within the past 105 days, thus eliminating routine visits for an ongoing case of MDD from the measure. https://ecqi.healthit.gov/ep/ecqms-2017-performance-period/adult-major-depressive-disorder-mdd-suicide-risk-assessment Propose revising the initial population logic by introducing a look back period of 105 days in order to limit the initial population to patients with a new or recurrent episode of MDD (if there is a gap of >=105 days between visits for MDD, clinical experts suggest that would imply a recurrent episode). PCPI also proposes to revise the classification of the ‘Major Depressive Disorder-Active’ diagnosis as an attribute of an encounter to ensure that the encounter is related to patient’s MDD. We seek feedback on the following proposed logic:   Current logic: •Initial Population = ◦AND: Age>= 17 year(s) at: "Measurement Period" ◦AND: "Diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active" starts during Occurrence A of $MDDEncounters161 •Denominator = ◦AND: Initial Population Variable: •$MDDEncounters161 = ◦Union of: ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psych Visit - Diagnostic Evaluation" ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psych Visit - Psychotherapy" ◾"Encounter, Performed: Emergency Department Visit" ◾"Encounter, Performed: Office Visit" ◾"Encounter, Performed: Outpatient Consultation" ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psychoanalysis" ◾"Encounter, Performed: Face-to-Face Interaction" ◾during "Measurement Period"   Proposed logic:   •Initial Population = ◦AND: Age>= 17 year(s) at: "Measurement Period" ◦AND: Occurrence A of $MDDEncounters161 ◦AND NOT: Occurrence B of $MDDEncounters161 < 105 days ends before start of Occurrence A of $MDDEncounters161 •Denominator = ◦AND: Initial Population   Variable: •$MDDEncounters161 = ◦Union of: ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psych Visit - Diagnostic Evaluation (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)” ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psych Visit – Psychotherapy (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)” ◾"Encounter, Performed: Emergency Department Visit (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)” ◾"Encounter, Performed: Office Visit (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)” ◾"Encounter, Performed: Outpatient Consultation (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)” ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psychoanalysis (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)” ◾"Encounter, Performed: Face-to-Face Interaction (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)” ◾during "Measurement Period"
    • Hide
      PCPI proposes revising the initial population logic by introducing a look back period of 105 days in order to limit the initial population to patients with a new or recurrent episode of MDD (if there is a gap of >=105 days between visits for MDD, clinical experts suggest that would imply a recurrent episode). PCPI also proposes to revise the classification of the ‘Major Depressive Disorder-Active’ diagnosis as an attribute of an encounter to ensure that the encounter is related to patient’s MDD.
       
       
      Current logic:
      •Initial Population =
      ◦AND: Age>= 17 year(s) at: "Measurement Period"
      ◦AND: "Diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active" starts during Occurrence A of $MDDEncounters161
      •Denominator =
      ◦AND: Initial Population
      Variable:
      •$MDDEncounters161 =
      ◦Union of:
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psych Visit - Diagnostic Evaluation"
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psych Visit - Psychotherapy"
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Emergency Department Visit"
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Office Visit"
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Outpatient Consultation"
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psychoanalysis"
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Face-to-Face Interaction"
      ◾during "Measurement Period"
       
      Proposed logic:
       
      •Initial Population =
      ◦AND: Age>= 17 year(s) at: "Measurement Period"
      ◦AND: Occurrence A of $MDDEncounters161
      ◦AND NOT: Occurrence B of $MDDEncounters161 < 105 days ends before start of Occurrence A of $MDDEncounters161
      •Denominator =
      ◦AND: Initial Population
       
      Variable:
      •$MDDEncounters161 =
      ◦Union of:
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psych Visit - Diagnostic Evaluation (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)”
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psych Visit – Psychotherapy (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)”
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Emergency Department Visit (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)”
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Office Visit (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)”
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Outpatient Consultation (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)”
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psychoanalysis (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)”
      ◾"Encounter, Performed: Face-to-Face Interaction (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)”
      ◾during "Measurement Period"
      Show
      PCPI proposes revising the initial population logic by introducing a look back period of 105 days in order to limit the initial population to patients with a new or recurrent episode of MDD (if there is a gap of >=105 days between visits for MDD, clinical experts suggest that would imply a recurrent episode). PCPI also proposes to revise the classification of the ‘Major Depressive Disorder-Active’ diagnosis as an attribute of an encounter to ensure that the encounter is related to patient’s MDD.     Current logic: •Initial Population = ◦AND: Age>= 17 year(s) at: "Measurement Period" ◦AND: "Diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active" starts during Occurrence A of $MDDEncounters161 •Denominator = ◦AND: Initial Population Variable: •$MDDEncounters161 = ◦Union of: ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psych Visit - Diagnostic Evaluation" ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psych Visit - Psychotherapy" ◾"Encounter, Performed: Emergency Department Visit" ◾"Encounter, Performed: Office Visit" ◾"Encounter, Performed: Outpatient Consultation" ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psychoanalysis" ◾"Encounter, Performed: Face-to-Face Interaction" ◾during "Measurement Period"   Proposed logic:   •Initial Population = ◦AND: Age>= 17 year(s) at: "Measurement Period" ◦AND: Occurrence A of $MDDEncounters161 ◦AND NOT: Occurrence B of $MDDEncounters161 < 105 days ends before start of Occurrence A of $MDDEncounters161 •Denominator = ◦AND: Initial Population   Variable: •$MDDEncounters161 = ◦Union of: ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psych Visit - Diagnostic Evaluation (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)” ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psych Visit – Psychotherapy (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)” ◾"Encounter, Performed: Emergency Department Visit (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)” ◾"Encounter, Performed: Office Visit (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)” ◾"Encounter, Performed: Outpatient Consultation (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)” ◾"Encounter, Performed: Psychoanalysis (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)” ◾"Encounter, Performed: Face-to-Face Interaction (diagnosis: Major Depressive Disorder-Active)” ◾during "Measurement Period"

      This measure is clearly designed to identify actions done at the first encounter with a new diagnosis. The guidance states that "It is expected that a suicide risk assessment will be completed at the visit during which a new diagnosis is made or at the visit during which a recurrent episode is first identified". This is reflected in the Population Criteria in the statement "◦AND: "Diagnosis, Active: Major Depressive Disorder-Active" starts during Occurrence A of $MDDEncounters161 "

      According to the current version of the QDM, "The QDM does not prescribe the source of diagnosis data in the EHR. Diagnoses may be found in a patient’s problem list, encounter diagnosis list, claims data, or other sources within the EHR."

      Where the problem arises here is when encounter diagnosis is used as a source of diagnosis data, as it is almost always available, and it can be expected to reflect the diagnoses that were addressed during the encounter, so it is a good source of data. Encounter diagnoses are a one time entry and basically have no time span, so for QDM purposes they start and end on the same day. So if you are looking at encounter diagnoses and deciding if it "started" on a given day (let's limit our consideration to outpatient encounters) then the decision will always be "yes", i.e. each encounter will evaluate to true.

      Therefore, what this measure is actually doing is evaluating whether a suicide assessment was done on every outpatient visit where depression was an encounter diagnosis, not just the first one.

      I assume there is a way to structure the language to just consider the first encounter, but maybe someone else can suggest how this would be done.

            edave Mathematica EC eCQM Team
            hbregman Howard Bregman (Inactive)
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            7 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved:
              Solution Posted On: