[CQM-7400] Guidance for OP-40 Procedure Time is not supported by QDM or FHIR Created: 11/01/24  Updated: 11/15/24  Resolved: 11/14/24

Status: Closed
Project: eCQM Issue Tracker
Component/s: None

Type: OQR eCQMs - Outpatient Quality Reporting Priority: Moderate
Reporter: Alex Liu Assignee: Mathematica EH eCQM Team
Resolution: Answered Votes: 1
Labels: None

Solution: **Revised response: 11/15/2024**
Thank you for your interest in the CMS996: Appropriate Treatment for ST-Segment Elevation Myocardial Infarction (STEMI) Patients in the Emergency Department (ED) measure. We appreciate your input on the measure specifications and guidance on capturing the PCI procedure. In accordance with the clinical guidelines, CMS recommends capturing device deployment time. The measure developer and CMS will consider refinements to the measure specifications in future Annual Updates.
Solution Posted On:
2025 Reporting Period Outpatient eCQMs:
CMS0996v5
2024 Reporting Period Outpatient eCQMs:
CMS0996v4
Impact: The guidance provided in CQM issues does not line up with data models. There is a misunderstanding of QDM and FHIR.
Last Commented Date:

 Description   

Many responses to OP-40 questions about PCI time have mentioned the need to prioritize balloon inflation time. The answers infer the intent of the measure and a hierarchy for data collection. These answers are unfortunate because this is not technically supported by QDM v5.6 or FHIR today.

Example responses:
CQM-6980
CQM-6984

The affected measure logic as published in CMS996v4 is as follows:

"ED Encounter with STEMI Diagnosis" EDwSTEMI
  with ["Procedure, Performed": "Percutaneous Coronary Intervention"] PCI
    such that Global."NormalizeInterval" ( PCI.relevantDatetime, PCI.relevantPeriod ) starts 90 minutes or less after Global."EmergencyDepartmentArrivalTime" ( EDwSTEMI )

As stated in QDM v5.6, A "Procedure, Performed" relevantPeriod references a start and stop time for a procedure that occurs over a time interval. The startTime references the time the procedure begins and the stopTime references the time the procedure ends. In QDM, it is inappropriate to pick a surgical event as the relevantPeriod.

Additionally in FHIR, there is not clarity on how individual surgical events should be represented; however, it is clear that it should not just be thrown into a performedPeriod FHIR-48449.

As of RY 2025, OP-40 is unusable and will provide inconsistent results. EHRs must be certified to the Quality Data Model definitions for data elements, so providing guidance that data should be manipulated or adding data hierarchies is a misinterpretation of QDM.

We do not disagree with the intent to capture PCI Balloon time. This is clearly the intention for a Door-to-Ballon metric; however, to improve this measure, the PCI data element must be transformed to a specific observation of "PCI Balloon Time." Without this adjustment, this measure will remain unusable.

 



 Comments   
Comment by Andrew Heiler (Inactive) [ 11/15/24 ]

Agree, this measure is not valid in its current state.
Andrew Heiler
Michigan Medicine

Comment by Mathematica EH eCQM Team [ 11/12/24 ]

We continue to investigate the issue noted in your ticket and will provide a response as soon as we are able. Thank you for your patience.

Comment by Mathematica EH eCQM Team [ 11/04/24 ]

Thank you for submitting your question. We will review your ticket and provide a response as soon as possible.

Comment by Howard Bregman (Inactive) [ 11/01/24 ]

Alex Liu is posting officially from Epic so this issue is going to affect many Epic-using provider organizations (and also those who use other EHRs). I agree with his comments.

Howard Bregman, MD, MS
Director, Clinical Informatics
Epic

Generated at Sat Apr 05 12:15:26 EDT 2025 using Jira 9.12.16#9120016-sha1:6bee0863f3e6dbb91e4be2d992a3b6761c21c9e0.